Connect with us

Real Estate

Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles- What’s the better option?



Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles

We all dream of buying the perfect house or building it from scratch and to make that dream come true, we are faced with many options to choose from. The floors, the windows, the roof- each and every part of the house needs to be perfect. This article focuses on the roof in particular and explores the two most popular options available in the market- asphalt shingles and metal roofing.

Asphalt roofing is the relatively older option, having been used for decades due to its cost-effectiveness, ease of maintenance and reliability. On the other hand, metal roofing is a relatively new concept but it is quickly catching the attention of homeowners.


Pros of Metal Roofing

Metal roofs were initially made of tin sheets grooved all over to give a wrinkly effect (standing seam metal). Metals used for this type of roofing include zinc, aluminum, and copper in various compositions. To get a better understanding of what metal roofing is all about, here are a few metal roofing advantages for buildings:

It is lightweight

One of the biggest reasons to opt for metal roofing is the fact that it is lightweight. Metal bars and sheets can easily be transferred up the ladder by the workers. It is also great for the house, in the sense that it protects the walls of the house from bearing down too much weight. If the roofing material is too heavy, it can damage the walls and pillars of the building.

Metal roofing lasts longer

The plus point of using metal to make your home’s roof is longevity. As compared to asphalt shingles, metal roofing will last longer and the minimum life span of a metal roof is at least 50 years.

Eco-friendly option for roofing

As you would know, metal is a reusable item that can easily be re-shaped into new products. Metals do not lose their characteristics after being recycled so it makes them a great option for roofing material. Whenever you would need to repair a damaged part of your metal roof, you would not need to throw away the metal parts. You can use them again as they can be recycled. Metal roofs create a minimum amount of waste which makes metal roofing highly eco-friendly.


Cons of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has some cons as well. Despite all the advantages, there is also a down-side to having a metal roof installed. Being light-weight works in its favor but the initial cost of installation is so high that it makes eco-friendliness an expensive feature.

Metal roofing has a greater one-time installation cost

High-tech equipment has to be used for the installation of the metal roof. Apart from that, skilled staff has to be hired to operate that equipment. Both, the machinery and skilled labor, cost a lot of money.


As discussed above, metal roofing requires specialized staff to properly install the roof. Installation of the metal roof has a number of stages, each with its own complex procedures. The work involved is so technical that it makes the roofing labor-intensive.

Contractors are not easy to find

As you know, metal roofing is a highly technical process requiring technical staff and equipment. Not many contractors will be willing to take such great responsibility.


Pros of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles give homes a traditional look, making the roof appear vintage and captivating. Indeed, shingle roofs are more commonly seen than metal roofing and that is because of the popularity. There are also other pros to having shingle roofing, like the ease of installation and access to materials.

Low initial cost

The initial cost of installation for shingle roofing is much lower than that of metal roofing. It is a simple process that does not require technical knowledge- a simple worker with no special training can perform the job. The material used is also cheap and easily available so the manufacturing cost is low. All these factors combined make asphalt roofing economical for the short term.

Repairs are not costly

Not only the installation but the repairs are also cheap. As the material is readily available, the cost of patching up a hole is rather low. The shingles can easily be removed and then replaced, near the area that is damaged. They are also small in size so you don’t have to remove a large chunk of the roof for a small repair.

You can find contractors easily

Shingle roofs have been around for almost a century, which means contractors can easily be booked for your roof installation.

You can walk on them

Shingle roofs give you the freedom to walk on your roof which is a luxury most of us would like to have. Walking on the roof without slipping cannot be achieved with metal roofs, that are plain and slippery.


Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Just like metal roofing, asphalt shingles also have a down-side.

Expensive in the long-run

Even though the asphalt shingle roofs are cheaper to install, they are much more expensive in the long-run. Metal roofs last longer than asphalt shingles, outlasting almost three shingle roofs, and that is because metal roofs are much more durable.

Prone to damage

The asphalt shingles can be damaged easily. Dust storms or heavy rain can chip off the material from the surface or break them. This can add up to your repair bills.


So, which one is better?

Amongst the two, the better option would be metal roofing. You might find the initial cost too much to handle but down the road, the cost is completely justified. It is also lightweight and cost-efficient.

Stahl Roof Systems provides easy metal roof installation, repair, and maintenance. We have highly advanced machinery and qualified installers who will make your home look brand new. Visit their site or blog for more information on roofing services, repair and maintenance.